Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Reasoning Under Uncertainty's avatar

Empirical alignment work carries its own check: does the benchmark number move, did the experiment replicate. Conceptual work, including the metric construction you place alongside it, has no equivalent feedback until someone judges whether the metric tracked what mattered.

That judgement is the same scarce capacity the field is trying to automate away. Getting strong automated empirical researchers before conceptual automation catches up means the fastest-growing capability lands on the step with the weakest verification, and I'd expect the risk to compound quietly: the empirical output keeps looking clean even as the targets it's optimising drift.

Ready for more?